Hood Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Hood community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Hood Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

POLL: Euthanization

who's talking here?

Michell 1
Jackymtz 1
*Jamie* 1
~*Crystal*~ 1
whisper 3
just stayc 4
{Morgan} 4
*bubbleheaded* 1
SillyPanda 1
Victoriana 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Euthanization

Ok, Dr. Kavorkian helped people die. Do you think it was a good thing or a bad thing? Yes I know it depends on the situation, let's say chances are grim, you're very old and at peace with yourself.

Good Vote
 
 59.1% (13)
Bad Vote
 
 40.9% (9)
{Morgan} --- 17 years ago -

Ok, Dr. Kavorkian helped people die. Do you think it was a good thing or a bad thing? Yes I know it depends on the situation, let's say chances are grim, you're very old and at peace with yourself. 

just stayc --- 17 years ago -

I think it's bad, when it's someone's time they will go ! he was trying to play God and that's not right . jmo ! 

{Morgan} --- 17 years ago -

I think it's good...of course in some case, I've known people that would beg almost daily to die because they were in so much pain....it's so sad that they have to suffer until "it's their time" 

*bubbleheaded* --- 17 years ago -

I think it's good...of course in some case, I've known people that would beg almost daily to die because they were in so much pain....it's so sad that they have to suffer until "it's their time" I agree with this. I have seen so many people beg and plead to just let them die. I think people should be able to decide if they want to continue suffering or not. If you are old and have lived a good life, then I think you should be able to leave this world with dignity. 

SillyPanda --- 17 years ago -

I think it's bad, when it's someone's time they will go ! he was trying to play God and that's not right . jmo ! soooo... when someone murders someone or they commit suicide, or someone has an abortion theyre playing god? because every time ive ever been to a mourning, and the family or friend died from suicide (which ive been to one) they were playing god? because the preist always said that god did it for the, to be in a better place. besides if its the persons choice to be euthanized becuase of pain and dying, youldnt you rather let them down easy like dogs getting euthanized or just let them take a gun to their head? 

just stayc --- 17 years ago -

I can see your point if they have it in a will or something, I was just reading up on him and it said that he claimed that's what the patients wanted. I totally understand if they are terminal . I had an uncle die from cancer who had tumors throughout his body and was totally suffering , he was put on morphine and died peacefully , I knew that he had suffered enough, and the morphine just eased the pain. I think if he would have asked for an assisted death I would have been more than willing to go along with his wishes. 

just stayc --- 17 years ago -

In a way yes, they are playing God, I have always heard the term "it's was their time" but it was because of someone else's actions that their life was taken. 

{Morgan} --- 17 years ago -

Well I'm an aethiest so....to me it just comes down to a humane death...I mean people put their pets to sleep when they are old and suffering, shouldn't humans get to make that decision as well? 

just stayc --- 17 years ago -

i was about to bring up the pet point, and u put it morgan , I haven't been down that road yet, but I would hope that she would go peacefully ! I guess I have a hard time letting go that's all :( 

*Jamie* --- 17 years ago -

This definitely comes down to whether you believe in God or not. I think it's wrong and is a sin. 

~*Crystal*~ --- 17 years ago -

I agree with this. I have seen so many people beg and plead to just let them die. I think people should be able to decide if they want to continue suffering or not. If you are old and have lived a good life, then I think you should be able to leave this world with dignity i agree if there just waiting to go and want to i think they should be allowed to 

Michell --- 17 years ago -

I have worked at a nursing home and have had people there beg me to just kill them because they hurt so bad... I think this doctor was helping pt's in the best way he thought.... There are pt's out there that have been going thru tons of treatments which have not helped them and they know they are dieing anyways, so why not do it if they are ready to go.... 

whisper --- 17 years ago -

I agree with it and Doctor K supposedly killed them with mercy and little pain involved. I would take that rather than have someone pull the plug and make me suffocate to death or whatever. 

Victoriana --- 17 years ago -

I agree with this 100% and feel it should be left up to a human being what is done with their body. I worked with terminal cancer patients for many years and I could not even begin to tell you how much suffering these people go through. Not daily, hourly but second by second. You can only give them so much pain medication and so often or you will kill them and all they are left to do is suffer. Most of them can't eat or sleep because the pain is so horrible. Some hospitals are starting to push for different methods of pain relief for patients finally in the form of long term spinal blocks similar to epidurals however those come with extensive risk as well so it will be awhile till those are perfected and approved. 

whisper --- 17 years ago -

after reading that Victoriana, I further my belief in it. I could never work with cancer patients. I admire you for having the courage to face that. 

{Morgan} --- 17 years ago -

Victoriana those are the people I was talking about. I have a few people that were close to me with cancer and it was so sad. 

Victoriana --- 17 years ago -

Thank you. It was not easy and I never want to do that again. The pain never goes away for these poor people. Even when we gave them medications that would make them sleepy, all it really did was make them to incoherent to actually complain out loud. I just wished the jury in Dr.Ks trial could have seen a lung cancer or pancreatic cancer patient in their last 30 minutes of life. 

whisper --- 17 years ago -

I just wished the jury in Dr.Ks trial could have seen a lung cancer or pancreatic cancer patient in their last 30 minutes of life. seriously!!! and you're welcome. You deserve it. :) 

Jackymtz --- 17 years ago -

I am not super religious but I have had one experience in life that taught me to never meddle with the natural course of life. My first son was diagnosed with a Neural Tube defect at 20wks gestation, his condition was "incompatible" with life, I could not bring myself to decide when his life should end so we carried him to term, He died during labor. It's a different situation but I couldn't carry the guilt of knowing i helped someone die. My opinions might change when i get older or if i'm the one in the predicament of a terrible ailment but as for now. I am against it 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Hood Underground